Drain Relining vs Excavation: Which Drain Repair Method Is Better?

Neither method wins every time. Drain relining suits cracked, leaking or root-damaged pipes that still hold their shape, because it repairs them from the inside with little or no digging. Excavation suits pipes that have collapsed badly, sit at the wrong gradient or need rerouting, because only digging up and replacing the pipe fixes those faults. A CCTV drain survey shows which method your drain needs.

The choice affects cost, disruption and how long the repair lasts. Relining done on a pipe that really needs replacing will fail early. Digging up a patio to fix a crack that a liner could seal causes disruption you didn’t need. This guide explains how each method works, what each one can and can’t fix, and how the decision affects your garden, driveway and timescale.

How Does Structural Drain Relining Work?

Structural relining, often called CIPP (cured-in-place pipe) lining, creates a new pipe inside the old one. The engineer works from an existing inspection chamber, so the ground above stays undisturbed. A typical job follows five stages:

  1. Survey and clean. The engineer surveys the pipe with CCTV, then jets it clean and cuts out roots or hardened deposits so the liner can sit tight against the old pipe wall.
  2. Measure and prepare the liner. The engineer cuts a flexible fibre liner to length and soaks it in resin.
  3. Insert the liner. Air pressure or a pull-in method feeds the liner into position, and an inflatable bladder presses it against the pipe wall.
  4. Cure the resin. The resin hardens in place, either on its own or with heat or UV light, depending on the system.
  5. Reopen connections and check. The engineer reopens any branch connections with a cutter and runs the camera through to record the finished lining.

For a short defect, a patch repair lines just a section of pipe, often under a metre long. For a run with defects along its length, a full-length liner covers it from chamber to chamber. Lining systems for drains and sewers have their own international standard, BS EN ISO 11296-4, which covers properties such as leak tightness, strength and resistance to jetting.

Drain relining equipment connected to an air compressor beside an open brick inspection chamber
Relining equipment set up at an inspection chamber during a NOW Drainage structural repair.

How Do Excavation and Pipe Replacement Work?

Excavation means digging down to the pipe, removing the damaged section and laying new pipe in its place. The engineer first traces the route and depth with CCTV and a locator and marks out the dig. The team then lifts the paving, turf or tarmac and excavates down to the pipe, supporting the trench where the depth or ground calls for it.

With the pipe exposed, the team cuts out the damaged length and lays new pipe, usually plastic, on a proper bed of granular material at the correct fall. New couplings join the replacement to the existing run, and the engineer tests the flow before the team backfills the trench in layers and reinstates the surface.

Excavation also lets the engineer change things relining can’t: adding a new inspection chamber, correcting the gradient, moving a pipe away from foundations or replacing a failed junction.

New orange drainage pipe laid in a trench beside a house wall, connecting to an inspection chamber
New pipework laid in a trench and connected to an inspection chamber during a drain replacement.

Relining vs Excavation: Advantages and Disadvantages

#Drain reliningExcavation and replacement
DisruptionLittle or none; works from existing chambersTrench through gardens, patios or driveways
Typical durationOften completed in a day for domestic runsLonger, depending on depth, length and surfaces
Fixes cracks, joints and rootsYesYes
Fixes collapsesOnly if the camera and liner can passYes
Fixes back-falls and wrong routesNoYes
Effect on pipe sizeSlightly reduces the internal diameterFull size, or upsized if needed
Surface reinstatementRarely neededAlways needed

Relining’s biggest advantage is that it avoids digging, so patios, driveways, extensions and mature planting stay in place. It seals every crack and joint along the lined length in one go, closes the joints that roots use to get in, and leaves a smooth resin surface that helps waste flow. Its limits come from the fact that a liner follows the existing pipe. It can’t correct a sag, a back-fall or a poor route, it needs a pipe the engineer can clean and get a camera through, and it slightly reduces the bore.

Excavation fixes any defect, including the ones relining can’t, and gives a brand-new pipe at the right depth and gradient. It also lets the team add access points that make future maintenance easier. The cost is disruption: lifting and relaying surfaces adds time, deep or long digs take longer still, and work near walls, trees or services needs extra care.

Which Types of Damage Suit Relining?

Relining suits pipes that have cracked or worn but still hold their shape. That covers cracks and fractures, open or slightly displaced joints, leaking pipes and joints, and surfaces worn rough enough to catch debris. It also suits root ingress through joints, once the engineer has cut the roots out, and minor deformation that a liner can still bridge.

In Poole, our engineers removed roots growing through defective clay joints, jetted the pipe and installed a cured-in-place liner to seal the joints without excavating the run. Our guide to tree roots in drains covers this type of repair in detail.

When Is Excavation Unavoidable?

Excavation becomes the only realistic option when the pipe itself is in the wrong shape or the wrong place. A collapse so severe that a camera or liner can’t pass needs digging out, and so does a section that has sunk into a dip or back-fall that holds water. Joints that have shifted too far for a liner to bridge fall into the same category.

Location and capacity matter too. A pipe that runs under a planned extension, a junction or chamber that has failed, or a pipe too small for the flow it now carries all need new pipework rather than a lining.

Some jobs need both methods. In Christchurch, our CCTV survey found a large collapse in an older clay drain. Our team returned the following week with two crews and structurally relined the damaged section from an existing chamber, avoiding a replacement of the whole run. Our guide to collapsed drain pipes explains the options for collapses.

Need to know which method your drain needs? Call NOW Drainage on 0800 001 6568 to book a CCTV survey. We agree a fixed price before any repair starts.

Disruption to Gardens, Driveways and Patios

Relining leaves your outside space largely untouched. The team works from inspection chambers, so the only signs of the job are the equipment and a van on the drive for the day.

Excavation needs a working trench along the damaged section. Turf can go back down, but block paving, patio slabs and tarmac need careful lifting and relaying. Tell the engineer about any surfaces you particularly value, because that can tip the decision towards relining where both methods would work.

In Talbot Woods, Bournemouth, our team excavated and replaced damaged clay sections with PVC pipework and new access points, then relined one section from inside to avoid digging next to the patio. The patio went back down neatly once the work finished.

New PVC drainage pipework installed to replace damaged clay pipes in Talbot Woods, Bournemouth
New PVC pipework in Talbot Woods, where our team combined excavation and relining.
Patio reinstated after drain repairs in Talbot Woods, Bournemouth
The reinstated patio after our Talbot Woods drain repair.

Typical Stages and Timescales

Every job differs, so treat these stages as a guide rather than a promise. A domestic relining job usually runs as survey, cleaning, lining, curing and a final camera check. Shorter patch repairs often fit into a single visit, while longer runs, several defects or pipes that need heavy cleaning first take longer.

An excavation job runs as survey, marking out, lifting surfaces, digging, replacing the pipe, testing, backfilling and reinstating. Depth, trench length, ground conditions, access and the type of surface all affect how long it takes. The engineer will give you an expected timescale for your job after the survey.

What Affects the Cost of Each Method?

Every drain differs, so NOW Drainage agrees a fixed price after the survey rather than quoting blind. The length of the damaged section makes the biggest difference: a short patch repair needs far less material and time than a full-length liner or a long trench. Depth and access add time to both methods, and especially to excavation, where lifting and relaying block paving, patio slabs or tarmac becomes part of the job.

The condition of the pipe matters as well. Heavy roots, scale or debris need extra cleaning before a liner can go in. Each branch connection a liner covers needs reopening afterwards, and a failed chamber needs rebuilding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is drain relining as good as replacing the pipe?

For cracks, leaking joints and root ingress, a properly installed structural liner gives a durable, jointless pipe inside the old one. It can’t fix a sagging or badly routed pipe, so for those defects replacement gives the better result.

Can you reline a collapsed drain?

Sometimes. If the collapse is partial and the engineer can clean the pipe and pass a camera and liner through, relining can bridge it. A severe collapse that blocks the pipe usually needs excavation.

Does relining reduce the size of the pipe?

Yes, slightly, because the liner adds a few millimetres of wall. In most domestic drains this makes no practical difference, and the smooth surface helps flow.

Will I need to move out during drain repairs?

Usually not. Relining often takes a day, and you may need to avoid using water for part of it. During excavation, the engineer will tell you when the drain is out of use and plan the work to keep that time short.

How do I know which method my drain needs?

A CCTV drain survey shows the type, position and severity of each defect. The engineer uses that evidence to recommend relining, excavation or a mix of both, and explains why.

The Bottom Line

Relining is the faster, tidier fix for cracked, leaking and root-damaged pipes that still hold their shape. Excavation is the right fix for severe collapses, sags and pipes in the wrong place. The camera, not guesswork, should make the decision.

Our drain repairs team carries out structural relining, patch repairs, excavation and pipe replacement across Dorset, Hampshire, Wiltshire, Bristol and Somerset. Every repair starts with a CCTV drain survey, we agree a fixed price before work starts, and we offer guarantees of up to 10 years on qualifying work.

Not sure which way your drain should go? Send us the details, or the footage from a previous survey, through our quote form, or call 0800 001 6568. We’ll tell you honestly whether a liner will do the job or whether the pipe needs to come out.